To get really tough on crime, we must help prisoners
Published by The Independent (8th February, 2016)
For many years ministers privately complained that even the most carefully chosen chief inspector of prisons rapidly went ‘native’, undermining their tough stances by bleating on about how bad life was behind bars. Now Nick Hardwick, the latest incumbent, has given insight into this phenomenon by announcing his departure on the grounds he was getting desensitised to the horrors. ‘You get used to things you shouldn’t get used to,’ he said.
Hardwick used two examples. One was men in cramped cells eating meals sitting on a bed by the toilet, which he said disturbed him at first but seemed almost normal now. The other was the epidemic of self-harm and suicide. Latest figures reveal 89 inmates killed themselves last year, compared with 58 in the year David Cameron became Prime Minister, while there have been similar sharp rises in the appalling levels of assaults and male self-harming.
Recent self-inflicted deaths include 21-year-old Luke Hughes. He was let down by prison authorities after begging for protection from gangs that forced him to ferry drugs, then became angry after he was caught. And Sarah Reed, 32, who suffered a severe mental breakdown after the death of her baby, was beaten by a police officer and then banged up in prison after an altercation in hospital, amid swirling allegations of attempted rape.
These stories illustrate how the state repeatedly lets down some of the most vulnerable people in its care: the addicts, the desperate and the disturbed who clog up our prisons. Many spend their lives in and out of jail, costing taxpayers a fortune clearing up their crimes and incarcerating them. Yet despite endless political talk about being tough on the causes of crime, their underlying problems are rarely tackled.
Prison is probably the single biggest indictment of state failure. Indeed, it is odd some right-wingers are such fans. Yet as Hardwick said, we are still waiting for the ‘rehabilitation revolution’ promised when the Tories took power in 2010. There were 85,634 people locked up last week – a few hundred more than when Cameron took office, despite the continuing drop in crime. About the only good news is a small fall in female inmates, although still far too many women are put in jail.
Ken Clarke tried his best as Justice Secretary but screwed up by alienating allies in Downing Street with his bloody-minded independence, while Chris Grayling was just a disaster. His successor, Michael Gove, has spent much of his first few months in the job clearing up the mess; indeed, it is bizarre his bungling predecessor still sits in Cabinet. Yet prison reform is an issue the Prime Minister cares deeply about and close aides say he is determined to transform our creaking criminal justice system.
Cameron has already announced a welcome inquiry into bias against black defendants. Today he will make a major speech on prisons, the first by a Prime Minister for more than two decades. No doubt there will be the usual cheap shots at foreign inmates, but the bulk of it will point out rightly that prisons are miserable places, filled with damaged individuals. Since most miscreants will be released again, we can only cut crime and costs to the public purse by addressing their educational and health needs.
Half have mental health problems while one quarter were in care as children. The Prime Minister, however, was stunned to discover the lack of data available to drive improved performance. Civil servants could not tell him which prison is even the best performer, let alone achieving good results in reducing recidivism or boosting qualifications. The system is so centralised almost 1,000 new instructions have been dictated from Whitehall in the past decade alone – which is 46,000 new pages of rules. These are so petty they even include how many sheets of music a prisoner can possess in his cell.
The government has already announced a much-needed prison rebuilding programme. As Gove told me on a visit to Wandsworth prison for a BBC Panorama programme I made last year, they want governors freed up to experiment and to bring in more providers of education. We also visited Texas together to see drug courts in action. These offer holistic support to tackle addiction and mental health problems with striking results; I met lethal gangsters, career criminals and crystal meth wrecks salvaged by this sensible system.
Now the Government plans to roll out huge expansion of such problem-solving courts, with their tough-but-tender approach to helping offenders sort out lives. This is good news. We need the Tories to break a political logjam that led England and Wales to have the highest imprisonment rate in Western Europe – just as the cause found unlikely champions in Texan Republicans who sparked changed attitudes across the United States. With Jeremy Corbyn leading Labour, there is a chance for rare consensus across the political spectrum.
Fine words must be followed by resolute action to face down those fools who see prison as an end in itself. For all the shrill nonsense talked about prison working, it is too often an expensive and egregious failure. Simply stuffing troubled human beings behind bars is a sign of political weakness. As one key Texan senator told me, he realised there is nothing strong about locking people up; far harder to force people to confront their demons. To get really tough on crime, we have to help perpetrators back into society.
Most recent articlesThe hellhole that refugees are forced to call home
Published by The Observer (7th February, 2016) City of Thorns: Nine Lives in the World’s Largest Refugee Camp (Portobello) Guled was a slight boy, orphaned in his teens and living on his wits in Mogadishu, a city reduced to ruins by years of interminable war. He lived with his sister and a swelling group of […]It’s easy to talk a good game on immigration
Published by The Independent (1st February, 2016) There is sometimes a single moment when talented young footballers do something so outrageous they declare themselves stars on the national stage. I was fortunate to be at Goodison Park when a stocky local kid scored a superbly arrogant goal against Arsenal in 2002, leading commentators to tell […]Where are the disabled actors?
Published by The Independent (25th January, 2016) A few months ago I was ploughing through the box set of the brilliant French thriller series Spiral. Much of the attention this dark drama series received focused on the strength of the main female character as she leads her team of police bruisers through the back streets […]The pollsters got it wrong – but they are still crucial for politicians
Published by The Daily Telegraph (20th January, 2016) Shortly before the 2010 general election, David Cameron sat down with the results of the latest in-depth opinion poll. It was a challenging time for the Tory leader, who had just a small lead over an unpopular Labour prime minister and a vote looming that would determine his […]Time to face the truth about immigration
Published by The Independent (January 18th, 2016) The mood across Europe is hardening as desperate people continue to pour across borders in search of sanctuary or escape from poverty. Hungary’s hardline leader has called for a ‘European defence line’ on Greek borders. Norway is ordering thousands of refugees to get back on bikes into Russia. […]How I learned to love the interfering state
Published by The Guardian (15th January, 2016) Political archaeology studies the influence of the past in shaping politics. It explains why New Labour hugged the Murdoch press even after it shredded a previous leader, and why some leading Tories adopted Tony Blair as a guru. And perhaps it explains why, as someone who first pondered […]Poison Penn
Published by The Daily Mail (12th January, 2016) The gangsters had a problem. Their Sinaloa cartel was killing so many people in the battle to control Mexico’s drug trade that it was struggling to dispose of the bodies, but there were limits to how many mutilated corpses could be dumped on roads and floated down […]Corbyn’s reshuffle shambles made Labour’s divisions even worse
Published by The Independent (11th January, 2016) Shortly after the appointment of Seumas Milne as Labour’s director of communications last year, he was overheard in a pub quizzing the BBC’s political editor, Laura Kuenssberg, for tips on how to do his new job. Clearly he did not take her advice. For now the pair are at […]How ‘Big Brother’ is destroying free speech in Rwanda
Published by The Observer (10th January) Bad News: Last Journalists in a Dictatorship by Anjan Sundaram (Bloomsbury) The text arrived one evening: ‘My life is in danger. I think I may die tonight.’ It came from Gibson, a talented young Rwandan journalist who was used to living in fear given his job. He avoided seeing […]We need to wake up to the NHS crisis
Published by The Independent (3rd January, 2016) There is one thing everyone can agree on: the last thing our nation needs right now is for thousands of doctors to down their scalpels and stethoscopes as the sickly National Health Service struggles for survival amid soaring pressures. Yet barring a last-minute breakthrough, the British Medical Association […]Spare us the toe-curling stunts of celebrities on foreign aid ego trips
Published by The Daily Mail (30th December, 2015) Perhaps actor Michael Sheen has spent too much time playing Tony Blair. For he seems to have developed similar disdain for the public in his latest role as a political activist. During his questionable stint as guest editor of BBC Radio 4’s Today programme on Monday, the […]Forget fear and loathing: 15 reasons to celebrate the world in 2015
Published by The Independent (28th December, 2015) Who will mourn the passing of 2015? It seems such a grim year filled with terrible tales of atrocities, extremism and terrorism. Mass murders in America, bigots unleashing bloody hell in Europe and that sickening mayhem in the Middle East makes the world seem daily more disturbing. It […]Carswell is right: it is time for Farage to step down
Published by The Independent (21st December, 2015) Politics often descends into farce, but rarely can there have been such an entertaining seasonal offering as the pantomime currently presented by Ukip. It is hard not to laugh when a fringe party reduced to only one MP by recent election failures has an outbreak of feuding between […]The £100m ghost camp for refugees
Published by The Mail on Sunday (20th December, 2015) The huge Azraq refugee camp appears over the horizon like an alien version of a music festival. Thousands of white metal huts are scattered around the rocky landscape and ringed by barbed-wire fences. Closer up, near the guarded entrance, a huge sign reads ‘Thank You’ to Britain, the […]A sickness at the heart of the NHS
Published by The Independent (14th December, 2015) Two weeks ago I went to a journalism awards ceremony at which the speaker was a man who blew the whistle on malpractice within the National Health Service rather than the usual comedian or TV personality inflicted on such events. Gary Walker, a former hospital trust chief executive, […]Why is Britain spending millions on flood aid abroad?
Published by The Daily Mail (9th December, 2015) The human drama being played out in Cumbria this week could hardly be more heartbreaking. Christmas trees, their baubles askew, lie forlornly in front gardens a foot deep in cloying mud, underscoring the fact that for hundreds of families, the festive season has been cancelled overnight. The agony […]Assad fanned the flames of extremism
Published by The Independent (7th December, 2015) How quickly the narrative changes. Just two years ago, our leaders insisted we could not stand idly by after Syria’s president was accused of using chemical warfare. We were warned about the dangers of inaction, told how global security was at stake and urged not to let crimes […]Ten years at the top – but trouble ahead on Syria and Brexit?
Published by The Mail on Sunday (6th December, 2015) Ten years ago today, a self-deprecating young politician called David Cameron took charge of the Conservatives – their fourth leader in eight years as the party struggled to adapt to 21st Century Britain. Few predicted he would capture the crown after just four years in Parliament. And yet, […]The tax-avoiding Facebook mogul and an act of charity that reeks of hypocrisy
Published by The Daily Mail (3rd December, 2015) Once, it was enough to put a notice in the newspaper when your child was born. But Mark Zuckerberg, the multi-billionaire founder of Facebook, likes to do things differently. So he welcomed his newborn daughter, Max, into the world with an open letter on his social media site, in […]Cameron’s long-awaited victory on Syria
Published by The Financial Times (3rd December, 2015) So here we go again. Britain has embarked on another military intervention, with Royal Air Force Tornado jets setting off from Cyprus to drop bombs on oilfields just hours after MPs sanctioned attacks on Syria. Prime minister David Cameron, while nervous about being blamed for the inevitable […]