A Minister for the Future might keep Britain on course
Published by The Independent (30th November, 2015)
Sweden is far from a nirvana, but it remains an innovative nation when it comes to politics and the problems confronting society. No one better exemplifies this than Kristina Persson, a cheerful 70-year-old with a long and varied record in public service. Last year this former trade union official, member of parliament and deputy governor of the central bank was given a new mission: to head up a ministry of the future.
The idea is brilliant in its simplicity: to force politicians to confront long-term issues facing their nation rather than focusing on short-term problems, driven by electoral calculations. As minister for strategic development, Persson has a brief to roam across the agenda regardless of normal department boundaries, operating almost like a government think-tank. ‘Policies need to change from within,’ she says. ‘There is a need to see any dangers in time and create a narrative that holds together.’
She has set up working parties of experts to examine three challenges: the threat to jobs from new technology, the transition to a green economy, and the impact of globalisation. These are tough issues with potentially unpopular solutions: after all, if unemployment rises thanks to robots and computers, can Western societies afford expensive welfare systems? Tackling climate change, meanwhile, demands policies peering half a century ahead from politicians more used to looking nervously at voters’ current utility bills.
What a sensible concept – especially after a spending review that raised more questions than it answered on big issues such as benefits, energy, health and social care. Just think about immigration: the influx powers our economy and props up the national health service, yet politicians stupidly focus on keeping numbers down. Or witness the myopic debate on health and social care, the fudging of infrastructure decisions and the minimal discussion of critical issues such as the future of the workplace.
As Persson says, politics must experiment with new solutions to retain support in a rapidly-changing world. So should Britain follow suit by appointing a pointy-headed political veteran such as Andrew Adonis or David Willetts to be our first minister for the future? Or perhaps we should mimic Finland, which for more than two decades has had a Committee for the Future in parliament to discuss trends and impact of new technologies, while also insisting governments deliver a detailed statement setting out how they see the future.
Certainly there can be no doubt short-termism bedevils British politics. Nowhere is this more evident than in the health arena with costs rising fast in an aging society, a system offering comparatively poor treatment record and social care provision on brink of collapse. Yet politicians shy away from fundamental debate over how to pay for services demanded by the public as they profess adoration of the system and respond to populism. And they duck difficult ethical issues, such as over the value of questionable end-of-life treatments.
Similar failures are evident on other long-term problems from energy security to pensions. ‘Unfortunately it is the classic political failure to only think about the next couple of years ahead,’ said one veteran Downing Street adviser. This is a core problem with democracy. Indeed, it is to the credit of politicians that despite the electoral straightjacket, many focus on future generations by backing costly infrastructure projects – although they also come up with silly solutions such as using Private Finance Initiative to build hospitals, storing up exorbitant future costs to resolve immediate political concerns.
The appointment of an official futurologist would be in keeping with current drift of politics. Both parties reacted to public distrust of Westminster by contracting out power to agencies and officials. Labour asked the Bank of England to set interest rates, the Coalition established the Office for Budget Responsibility to analyse public finances and the Tories have created a National Infrastructure Commission to advise on major projects.
Yet a solitary minister might be too easily ignored. Frank Field proved this when asked by Tony Blair to ‘think the unthinkable’ on welfare, only to have his reforms rejected – although. Blair later claimed the problem was ‘not so much that his thoughts were unthinkable as unfathomable’. So perhaps better to adopt the Finnish model with a powerful new select committee, made up from both houses of Parliament to derive maximum strength and draw from the widest expertise. Or maybe just create another powerful new Whitehall agency.
Such a move might ensure a focus on neglected issues. It could also provide valuable political cover for unpopular but necessary policies. Imagine a new chancellor wanting to confront the welfare bias towards pensioners, who have kept free television licences and bus passes amid austerity for fear of upsetting the section of society most likely to vote. How much easier if there was a report by the state future-gazers insisting this should be done? Or to permit housebuilding on green belt in order to unblock the planning logjam? Or to wriggle off the absurd aid target placed in law?
The Prime Minister is a fan of Nordic government as well as its drama. So what does he have to lose from importing this clever concept? It offers a potential tool to help restore trust in politics, recast the state, recalibrate misfiring policies and resolve the thorniest issues of our age. This focus on the future feels like an idea whose time has arrived.
Most recent articlesA daft giveaway that feeds corruption
Published by The Mail on Sunday (29th November, 2015) Every day, the British aid splurge becomes more absurd. Despite austerity at home, the sums donated abroad will double during David Cameron’s period as Prime Minister – from about £8 billion in 2010 to more than £16 billion by the next Election. Yet, as even Chancellor […]Family tragedy shines penetrating light on failures of state care
Published by The Daily Mail (26th November, 2015) The case of the Clarence family is one of the most harrowing to have hit the headlines in recent years: a loving mother who cracked under the intense pressure of caring for her three severely disabled children and smothered them to death. It is impossible not to […]The chancellor is for turning… thank goodness
Published by The Daily Telegraph (25th November, 2015) The scope of the spending review was immense with a fusillade of major announcements on everything from health to housing, social care to sport. This was a big political moment, one that will play a key role shaping the state and defining the first Tory government of […]Putin, tangled foreign policy and a flawed case for war
Published by The Independent (23rd November, 2015) France is not the only part of Europe under a state of emergency. All four power lines supplying electricity to two million Crimeans were blown up on Saturday night. The attack appeared to be the work of Ukrainian activists, since images were circulating on social media showing the […]Why Mali was attacked
Published by CapX (20th November, 2015) & The Independent (21st November, 2015) So here we go again. First the tragic slaughter of innocents in Paris, followed by that tense, bloodstained hunt for the murderers. Now 170 largely-foreign hostages have been seized by gunmen in an upmarket hotel in the Malian capital of Bamako. The 140 […]Don’t just pay glib respects. Pay your taxes to protect us
Published by The Sun (20th November, 2015) It did not take long for the world’s technology giants to react when cowardly gangsters unleashed bloody carnage and terrifying chaos on the streets of Paris last Friday. First came the spread of news, analysis and rumours on social media, with 7,000 tweets a second at one stage […]To turn on refugees because of Paris is weak and wrong
Published by The Guardian (18th November, 2015) Should we ban white Australians from coming to Britain? After all, one misfit teenager from Melbourne became so disillusioned with western life that he went to Iraq and reportedly blew himself up as an Islamic State suicide bomber earlier this year. With his long hair and love of […]Iceland has jailed 26 bankers, so why won’t we?
Published by The Independent (16th November, 2015) There are many reasons to admire Iceland, but here is another one: it has just sentenced five senior bankers and one prominent investor to prison for crimes relating to the economic meltdown in 2008. And with these two separate rulings made last month in the Supreme Court and […]Cut down doing the job he loved
Published by The Mail on Sunday (15th November, 2015) It is hard to think of anyone further removed from the fanaticism and hatred of Islamist killers than Nick Alexander, who was working at the Bataclan theatre when the gunmen slaughtered scores of music fans. The 36-year-old was selling merchandise for the band playing at the […]Are we brave enough to reform a system in crisis?
Published by The Mail on Sunday (15th November, 2015) The National Health Service is in a mess – and we are reaching the crunch point for its survival in the shape we have known for almost seven decades. It has, of course, been in near-permanent crisis since the day it was born. But the costs […]Drug warriors being defeated, but Britain fights on
Published by The Independent (9th November, 2015) There can be no doubt that the daft war on drugs is devastating many of the world’s poorest countries, from Africa to Latin America. But this has been ignored by major charities that claim to campaign for international development, presumably for fear of upsetting their donors. Now one has broken […]Foreign aid fat cats face greater scrutiny
Published by The Mail on Sunday (8th November, 2015) Ministers have ordered a crackdown on private firms making massive profits from Britain’s foreign-aid spending after their activities were exposed by The Mail on Sunday. International Development Secretary Justine Greening summoned foreign-aid fat cats to a meeting last month at which they were told they faced […]Transatlantic lessons from the Republican civil war
Published by The Independent (2nd November, 2015) Almost from the moment he became a senator four years ago, Marco Rubio has been marked out as a potential Republican saviour. This savvy son of Cuban immigrants is seen as the man who could win back the White House from the Democrats, with the ability to create […]Britain is embracing diversity. So why are people with disabilities still excluded?
Published by The Guardian (30th October, 2015) Rejoice, rejoice. Britain’s biggest companies hit a target of ensuring half the population have one quarter to seats in their boardrooms. Sarcasm aside, this is cause for a degree of celebration, since the proportion of women at this top level of business governance has doubled in four years. Most […]Diplomatic impotence – or disregard for human rights
Published by The Independent (26th October, 2015) The visit of Xi Jinping was deemed a success on both sides. Our royal family ensured China’s president was pampered with immense pomp and pageantry, while our political rulers discussed business deals and Britain’s creaking energy system. Human rights were swept under the red carpet, platitudinous speeches were given […]The Spice Academy
Published by The Mail on Sunday (25th October, 2015) She is the singer who scored an incredible nine No 1 singles, flirted with Prince Charles and exhorted young fans to make sure they got what they really, really wanted. Now aged 43, and settled down with a daughter and a Grand Prix tycoon husband, former […]There’s outrage over steel, but we should be furious over solar power
Published by The Guardian (23rd October, 2015) The former Tory party chairman Grant Shapps is promoting renewable energy in his new role as minister for Africa. Launching a bid to exploit British prowess in the booming solar sector and aid the poor, he insisted governments should be attracted by an energy source that is ‘so much […]China’s economic growth is a force for good
Published by The Daily Telegraph (21st October, 2015) As Britain rolls out the red carpet for China’s president, draping the communist leader in as much pomp and circumstance as can be mustered, there is excitable talk of a “golden era” in our relationship with Beijing. Difficult issues such as cyber-terrorism and human rights are brushed under […]Want to avoid a Brexit? Then run a campaign of fear
Published by The Independent (19th October, 2015) There are about 60,000 colonies of great crested newts among the ponds of Britain, although even conservationists say they have no idea about total numbers of the amphibians. Yet under European Union regulations, just one of these warty creatures can stop a development, delaying projects for months while […]The fat city that declared war on obesity
Published by Mosaic (13th October, 2015) & The Atlantic (14th October, 2015) When Velveth Monterroso arrived in the USA from her hometown in Guatemala, she weighed exactly 10 stone. But after a decade of living in Oklahoma, she was more than five stone heavier and fighting diabetes at the age of 34. This friendly woman, a […]