Is Tim Farron really a liberal at all?
Published by The Guardian (25th June, 2015)
It has been largely forgotten, but two of the nation’s major political parties are now engaged in leadership contests. While the quartet of Labour candidates received prime-time television coverage for their dreary and uninspiring debate, the two men fighting over the twitching corpse of the Liberal Democrat party struggle to gain much media interest for the minor league contest.
Politics is brutal, but the speed with which the Lib Dems went from party of government led by the deputy prime minister to a near-invisible parliamentary minnow is breathtaking. Already it seems strange that Nick Clegg was such a Westminster player that even his most banal utterances made headlines. The untimely death of Charles Kennedy served as cruel reminder of a shrunken party’s reversion to the impotence of its past.
Yet the contest matters. The Labour party seems to be curling up, having lost confidence in either itself or the future amid growing insularity on the left. Meanwhile there are concerns that a Conservative government with a slender majority might be held hostage by headbangers on the hard right, already flexing their muscles just one month after David Cameron’s electoral triumph.
In this climate, with crackdowns on civil liberties, debate over human rights, a ballot on Europe and widespread hostility to migrants, Britain needs a strong liberal voice to challenge the two main parties if they drift back towards their comfort zones. Yet the force that historically held this flag aloft is fighting for survival after its catastrophic decision to enter coalition, a dismal campaign, and having lost not just 49 of its 57 MPs but also all but one of its MEPs, half its councillors and two-thirds of its voters.
So it seems baffling that the party might elect as leader a man who seems to lack a driving spirit of liberalism – especially when such beliefs resonate more strongly with younger people. The frontrunner, Tim Farron, has never hidden his ambition. His energetic campaigning, support for immigration and opposition to the bedroom tax deserve credit. But he does not seem inspired by the distrust of the state, freedom for individuals and, above all, instinctive tolerance that are hallmarks of his party’s traditional creed.
This is evident on social issues, where his evangelical Christianity appears to collide with the cause of liberalism. Although an atheist, I admire people inspired by faith into fighting for others. And if Norman Lamb, the other leadership candidate, feels his aides have been abusing this issue, he was right to apologise this week when the pair clashed on Victoria Derbyshire’s BBC programme. Yet there is a legitimate issue of degree and substance: how can the party of liberalism have a leader so driven by his belief in the Bible that religious devotion trumps political principles when they clash? As Peter Tatchell says, religious beliefs are fine but they should not be translated into discriminatory legislation.
When the contenders discussed abortion, Farron said he supported a woman’s legal right to terminate a pregnancy. But in an interview with the Salvation Army’s paper a couple of years after he was first elected, he said starkly: ‘Abortion is wrong. Society has to climb down from the position that says there is nothing morally objectionable about abortion before a certain time. If abortion is wrong, it is wrong at any time.’
He may not want a ban restored, but surely anyone professing to be a liberal should not undermine a woman’s right to choose? It was, after all, David Steel – then a young Liberal MP – who introduced the bill that in effect legalised abortion almost half a century ago. Yet according to anti-abortion groups, Farron has never opposed them during his decade in parliament, voting once on their side and either being absent or abstaining on nine occasions.
His right to personal faith must be respected. But Lib Dem members also have the right to ask if Farron’s religious fervour would be a help or hindrance to their party’s salvation. What, for instance, do they make of his past demand that a quango produce ‘indisputable scientific evidence’ to prove God does not heal people with medical conditions? He later issued an apology for the absurdity.
And what of his dubious record on lesbian and gay equality? He has missed, abstained and even voted against important legal landmarks. Although Farron voted in favour of gay marriage, the campaign group Stonewall, reviewing his first five years in parliament, said he failed to support their position on significant votes.
The same lack of liberalism can be seen in Farron’s support for higher income taxes and protectionist economic policies. This may impress some party activists, but there is no more future for the Lib Dems as a pale imitation Labour party than as chummy colleagues of the Conservatives. His opponent is not overburdened with charisma, but Lamb at least seems to be fashioning a liberal stance on criminal justice and drug reform.
These are dark days for the Lib Dems, but if they look back into their past they might glimpse a path into the future. When Jo Grimond became Liberal leader in 1956, he inherited a wounded party with six seats and a share of the vote that was under 3%. He inspired a new generation with passionate social liberalism, helping to pave the way for the great Labour reforms of the 1960s, combined with the sort of small-state economic liberalism that found an echo in Margaret Thatcher’s Tories. This saved his party from death.
Grimond once said ‘divisions in politics fall in all the wrong places’, which remains true today. Liberalism remains a vital component of the political spectrum. Yet despite its great history, there is no guarantee that the party that nominally claims to represent it must survive in turbulent political times. Once thing is sure as the Lib Dems struggle to regroup: the last thing they or the country need is to be led by someone who does not seem to be a heartfelt liberal.
Most recent articlesThe political response to Europe’s migration crisis has been shameful
Published by The Independent (22nd June, 2015) A few days ago I was sitting in Athens with an official from Médecins Sans Frontières discussing the migration crisis confronting Europe. She was showing me maps filled with swirling red arrows, denoting the most common and current routes across the Mediterranean. The tide of human flotsam washed […]Horror for a senior detective
Published by The Mail on Sunday (21st June, 2015) During 28 years as a detective, Phil Gormley thought he had seen it all, from vicious rapes to brutal murders. Like other police officers, he has also had to confront sickening evidence of child sex abuse. Yet the former chief constable – now deputy director general […]Crime chiefs warn 750,000 British men may be attracted to children
Published by The Mail on Sunday (21st June, 2015) Up to 750,000 men living in Britain may have an interest in having sex with children, the Government has been warned. A shocking analysis by the National Crime Agency reveals that about one in 35 adult males poses a potential risk of being a child abuser […]Why a trick of the mind can make you blind
Published by The Daily Mail (18th June, 2015) It’s All In Your Head by Suzanne O’Sullivan (Chalto & Windus) Life was good for Camilla. She was a successful family lawyer, mother of two children and happily married to an old college friend who had become a partner in a law firm. Then one day, while on a […]A country that is dying to leave the euro
Published by The Mail on Sunday (14th June, 2015) How does a nation die? This week, in the beleaguered hospitals of Athens, I saw a glimpse of the shocking answer. It is when its own people die in their thousands simply because the state cannot afford to heal them. In the Reichstag in Berlin, it […]Brothers in arms – but Bush and Blair take divergent paths now
Published by The Independent (9th June, 2015) When he left the White House in early 2009 and headed back to Dallas, few people were sad to see George W Bush depart from highest office. Americans were aching for him to go. The 43rd president of the United States was seen by most fellow citizens as […]Why is David Cameron handing out £12bn of our money to foreign thieves, dictators and charlatans?
Published by The Mail on Sunday (7th June, 2015) Dear Prime Minister It is a decade since we began striving together to transform the Conservative Party into a modern force fit for government, so I was delighted to see you confound your critics again at last month’s Election. You can take great pleasure in your […]Who will put Greece out of its misery?
Published by The Daily Telegraph (5th June, 2015) Omonia Square used to be the thriving commercial heart of the Greek capital. But when I was there I saw only depressing scenes: scores of shops closed down, banks with steel shutters covered in angry graffiti and chaos on the roads since traffic lights had been destroyed […]Why the Tories should take Miliband’s attack on business seriously
Published by CapX (5th June, 2015) It is still less than one month since that astonishing election result, but already the idea of Ed Miliband as prime minister seems more like some kind of weird fantasy than a potential reality threatening the nation. Yet there is something rather unseemly about the speed and vigour with […]The ban on legal highs is mind-bendingly stupid
Published by The Independent (1st June, 2015) Sometimes it is hard not to wonder at the stupidity of Westminster. Advanced nations around the world are waking up to the failure of the war on drugs, with more than 20 countries introducing forms of decriminalisation. From Lisbon and Prague to Mexico City, Montevideo and Washington, policy-makers […]Blair’s legacy in Middle East is peace poor
Published by The Sun (29th May, 2015) Once he promised to transform Britain. Instead Tony Blair became a despised figure around the world. And now what is probably the final act in Tony Blair’s political career has ended in abject failure as he leaves his job as Middle East peace envoy. Given his dismal record, there […]Labour’s instant denial of its manifesto damages politics
Published by The Independent (25th May, 2015) Politics is a brutal business – and none know this better than Ed Balls. The Brownite bruiser, a less than popular figure in his own party as well as among opponents, has confessed to friends that he was distraught to lose his West Yorkshire seat, such was his […]Shamed: foreign aid fat cats who built a fortune with your taxes
Published by The Mail on Sunday (24th May, 2015) Caroline Pinder passionately believes in the power of aid to help the world’s poor. She has dedicated the past 25 years of her life to this cause, working on projects often supported by British taxpayers in two dozen countries from Albania to Zimbabwe. But last month […]Could Michael Gove become a liberal hero by reforming prisons?
Published by The Guardian (20th May, 2015) The appointment of Michael Gove as justice secretary was among the more interesting appointments in David Cameron’s first all-Conservative cabinet. Attention has focused on his brief to scrap the Human Rights Act, which some suspect was a Conservative manifesto sop for the right to be negotiated away in coalition […]£400m foreign aid fiasco in paradise
Published by The Mail on Sunday (17th May, 2015) Sean McLaughlin had a simple dream – to build a new life in paradise while helping the island community of his wife’s family recover from devastating natural disasters. But this week he will bid farewell to the Caribbean idyll of Montserrat. He is flying back to […]Divas who think they can’t sing
Published by The Daily Mail (15th May, 2015) Naked at the Albert Hall: The Inside Story of Singing (Virago) Dusty Springfield became a star with that smokey, sensual voice. Yet while many fans adored and envied her special talent, she exemplified the tortured artist with her self-doubt and ultimately rather sad life. These anxieties explained […]The false prophets of nationalism
Published by The Independent (11th May, 2015) Shortly before election day I spent an afternoon with the affable Danny Alexander as he fought to save his seat in north-east Scotland. This decent man was an unexpected star of the Coalition but for all his brave talk must have known his campaign was doomed, victim of […]Triumph, despair and revenge at the British ballot box
Published by The Wall Street Journal (9th May, 2015) On Thursday evening, as the final voters were trudging to polling stations, David Cameron was handed his party’s predictions for the British general election. The tally suggested that his Conservatives would win 295 seats — significantly shy of the 323 needed for a majority in Parliament. That estimate […]Stunning victory leaves Cameron awash with political capital
Published by The Independent (8th May, 2015) This stunning election victory is something to savour for David Cameron. It is a personal triumph that trounces not just political rivals, the pollsters and most pundits but also the many detractors inside his own party. I know of one right-wing former minister who had been planning to demand the […]Britain is winning the star wars
Published by CapX (7th May, 2015) What more could a chancellor have wanted on the eve of an election? No wonder George Osborne looked so pleased when he trucked along to Ealing Studios on Monday to reveal the next Star Wars would be filmed in Britain. For this dream announcement allowed him to announce the […]